How Homeowners Can Fight Back Against Rising Insurance Costs
Across the country, homeowners are feeling the squeeze of rising insurance premiums. From Florida to California and everywhere in between, the increasing number of severe weather events, natural disasters, and large claim payouts have caused insurance companies to pass higher costs onto homeowners. Unfortunately, relief doesn’t appear to be in sight anytime soon.
But that doesn’t mean you’re powerless. There are several strategies you can use to keep your homeowners insurance costs under control without sacrificing necessary coverage.
1. Re-Shop Your Policy Regularly
One of the most effective strategies is to get a new quote every 12–18 months. Don’t just stick with your current provider — insurance rates shift constantly. The company that was the most expensive last time you quoted may now be the most affordable.
👉 Compare multiple quotes here
2. Use a Broker, Not Just One Provider
Instead of calling only the “big names” like State Farm, Shelter, or Allstate, consider working with a broker. A broker shops rates across multiple carriers on your behalf, saving you time and often finding options you may not have considered.
3. Adjust Your Deductibles
Raising your deductible can be a smart way to lower your monthly premium. Just make sure you keep enough emergency funds set aside to cover the higher out-of-pocket cost if a claim arises.
4. Explore Policy Options: ACV vs. Replacement
Many homeowners don’t realize the difference between Actual Cash Value (ACV) policies and Replacement Cost coverage. Replacement policies generally cost more but pay for full replacement. ACV policies cost less but subtract depreciation. Some carriers even offer hybrid policies where roofs, for example, are covered at ACV while the rest of the home is covered at replacement.
5. Other Cost-Saving Tips
-
Bundle your home and auto insurance
-
Improve your credit score (yes, insurers use this)
-
Invest in security systems or wind/hail-resistant roofing materials for discounts
-
Ask about loyalty or claims-free discounts
Final Thoughts
Insurance is one of the biggest hidden costs of homeownership, and with premiums climbing, it pays to be proactive. At House Buyers OKC, we know how important managing costs can be — especially if you’re already juggling high mortgage payments or unexpected repairs.
If you ever find yourself in a situation where insurance, taxes, or repairs make your house feel like too much to handle, selling your home as-is might be the smartest option. That’s where we can help.
👉 Learn how we buy houses in Oklahoma City as-is
Frequently Asked Questions About Homeowners Insurance Costs
What is the average deductible for homeowners insurance?
Most homeowners carry a deductible between $1,000 and $2,500, but raising it higher can significantly reduce your premiums if you have the financial cushion to cover a larger out-of-pocket expense.
Is it cheaper to work with an insurance broker?
Yes, often brokers can save you money because they compare rates across multiple companies. However, it’s smart to still do your own shopping for comparison.
How often should I shop for new homeowners insurance?
Experts recommend getting quotes at least every 12–18 months, since rates change quickly based on claims history, natural disaster trends, and carrier competition.
What’s the difference between Actual Cash Value and Replacement Cost?
-
Replacement Cost pays to fully replace the damaged property.
-
Actual Cash Value (ACV) pays the depreciated value. ACV is cheaper but may leave you covering more out-of-pocket.
Can home improvements lower my insurance premium?
Yes — upgrades like a new roof, storm shutters, a monitored alarm system, or wind-resistant materials often qualify for discounts with many carriers.

